Should we allow care robots?
Jeremy Peckham - Research Lead at the AI, Faith and Civil Society Commission
As the global population ages, healthcare systems in both developed and developing nations are facing growing challenges. In this context, AI and robotics have been touted as potential solutions to alleviate pressure on healthcare systems. Virtual health assistants like Alexa, care robots, automated image analysis, robot-assisted surgery, and telemedicine are some of the innovations driving this shift. However, the increasing reliance on AI and robotics in caregiving raises ethical concerns related to the preservation of human connection, responsibility, and compassion in healthcare.
Key Applications in Healthcare and Caregiving
Paro – The Robot Baby Seal
One notable example is Paro, a therapeutic robot designed to resemble a baby seal. It has gained popularity in care homes for dementia patients, where its interactive capabilities provide emotional comfort to those suffering from the disease. The robot responds to touch, voice, and light, mimicking the behaviours of a real animal, which helps calm patients and alleviate their feelings of loneliness. While Paro offers a form of companionship and emotional support, its use raises the question of whether bonding with a robot can replace the comfort of human connection, particularly for individuals in vulnerable states like dementia patients.
Heavy Lifting and Assistive Robotics
Robots are also being used to assist with physical tasks in healthcare settings, such as lifting patients, transferring them to wheelchairs, or repositioning them in bed. These robots, while helpful in reducing physical strain on healthcare workers and improving efficiency, do not replace the empathy and emotional connection provided by human caregivers. Although these robotic systems are designed to replicate certain human interactions, they lack the ability to offer emotional comfort or respond with the sensitivity and care that human caregivers bring to their work.
A Key Problem: Love, Compassion, and Moral Responsibility
The increasing reliance on robots for caregiving tasks poses significant ethical challenges related to love and compassion in society. Robots may perform functional caregiving tasks, but they cannot replicate the deep emotional engagement and empathy provided by human caregivers. This raises concerns about whether society will become less compassionate as more caregiving responsibilities are transferred to machines. The heart of the issue lies in the nature of care: is it enough to provide functional support, or do we risk losing something fundamental about what it means to care and love for another person?
The introduction of robots into caregiving also presents the ethical dilemma of transferring moral responsibility. If we increasingly rely on robots to care for our loved ones, especially as these machines become more capable and sophisticated, we may begin to feel less guilty about not fulfilling our caregiving duties ourselves. The challenge is understanding how this shift in responsibility might alter our moral character and the virtues of empathy, compassion, and responsibility that have traditionally defined human caregiving.
Human Values Risk Analysis
Truth and Reality – High Risk
As AI and robots become more integrated into healthcare, there is a risk of blurring the line between human and machine interactions. This shift could lead to a diminished sense of reality, where individuals, particularly vulnerable populations like the elderly or those with dementia, may become more emotionally attached to machines than to real people.
Authentic Relationships – High Risk
While robots can provide comfort and assistance, they do not possess the ability to offer genuine human emotional engagement. Over-reliance on robots could weaken human connections, which are vital for mental and emotional well-being, especially in settings like nursing homes or hospitals where emotional support is crucial.
Moral Autonomy – Medium Risk
As robots take over caregiving tasks, individuals may lose their sense of responsibility for the care of others. This shift in responsibility could lead to a devaluation of moral agency, where people feel less accountable for the well-being of their loved ones.
Dignity of Work – Medium Risk
While robots can assist with physical tasks, they cannot replace the emotional and relational aspects of caregiving. Human caregivers play an irreplaceable role in offering empathy, companionship, and emotional support, which are integral to the dignity of their work.
Cognition and Creativity – Low Risk
The introduction of AI and robots into caregiving is unlikely to directly impact human cognition or creativity. However, the over-reliance on automated systems could lead to a decline in critical thinking in healthcare settings, particularly if decisions are increasingly made by AI algorithms rather than human judgment.
Privacy and Freedom – Low Risk
The use of AI in healthcare raises some concerns about privacy, particularly with the collection and analysis of patient data.
Policy Recommendations
- Regulate AI and Robotics in Caregiving
Establish guidelines and regulations governing the use of robots in caregiving settings to ensure that they are used in a way that supports, rather than replaces, human relationships. Policies should focus on maintaining the emotional and relational aspects of caregiving, such as requiring human oversight in caregiving environments where robots are used - Human Oversight of AI and Robotics:
AI systems and robots should always operate under human supervision, especially in critical caregiving tasks. This ensures that ethical considerations, such as empathy and moral responsibility, are factored into decision-making processes. Additionally, caregivers should retain the ability to intervene in robotic actions, maintaining the human element of care - Strengthen Privacy Protections in Healthcare Technology:
It is essential to ensure that personal health data collected through these technologies is protected. Governments should strengthen data protection laws, ensuring that patients’ privacy is respected when using AI and robotics in healthcare settings.
References
A. Johnston, Robotic Seals Comfort Dementia Patients but Raise Ethical Concerns, San Francisco: KALW [San Francisco Local Public Radio], 17 August 2015, retrieved on 11 September 2019 from .
Easing Caregiving Stress: A Guide to Buying an Elder Care Robot